Saturday, April 24, 2010

Intermodalism: Sacramento Style

With the early 2010 announcement of the projects selected by the Obama Administration for high-speed and intercity passenger rail, much observation and commentary on the issue has focused on the need to compliment the projects with the so-called first and last mile of a trip, meaning how does a passenger traveling on a high-speed or intercity train get to and from the station? In fact, the President himself described his vision of the concept, saying:


"What we're talking about is a vision for high-speed rail in America.  Imagine boarding a train in the center of a city. No racing to an airport and across a terminal, no delays, no sitting on the tarmac, no lost luggage, no taking off your shoes. Imagine whisking through towns at speeds over 100 miles an hour, walking only a few steps to public transportation, and ending up just blocks from your destination. Imagine what a great project that would be to rebuild America."


The idea of coordinating connections between modes of travel at a central nexus – like a train station – is, of course, not a new concept by any means. Early in our nation's development, port cities found immense centers of travel activity near their docks and wharves. As the railroads stretched across the continent, train stations became the crux of community life in the smallest towns and largest cities. However, as travel by automobile and air emerged as the preferred modes of travel in the second half of the twentieth century, less priority was placed on organizing transportation options in a single location. This trend has begun to reverse itself, however, in recent decades, as new travel hubs uniting rail, bus, taxi, bicycle and pedestrian routes have been established – or reestablished in many communities. 

Some commentators discussing how these intermodal facilities would amplify the opportunities offered by high-speed rail often describe a utopian-sounding environment where high-speed trains glide into a stunning glass atrium station to find frequent and easy to access connections to regional commuter rail and local rail transit – such as subways, light-rail and streetcars – alongside local and intercity bus service, taxi stands, bicycle racks or lockers and well-appointed pedestrian paths to reach nearby attractions such as central business districts or historical sites. These observers would prefer to position such a facility at or near a historical and well-maintained passenger rail station, too. Sounds like a pretty fanciful concept, eh? Maybe something more suited to a progressive European capital like Amsterdam or Prague, or perhaps possibly in that outside-the-box enclave of Portland, Ore? Except for the high-speed rail, all this is already happening in Sacramento, Calif.

Sacramento is one the nation's most historic railroading cities – after possibly Baltimore and Chicago – and perhaps the most important one in California. It was here that the legendary "Big Four" investors in the Central Pacific Railroad – Leland Stanford, Collis Huntington, Charles Crocker and Mark Hopkins, along with engineer Theodore Judah – launched the railroad that would connect with the Union Pacific at Promontory Point, Utah to complete the Transcontinental Railroad. Trains crossing the route would terminate here, before connections were established later on to reach the Bay Area and the San Joaquin Valley. The Central Pacific would ultimately become the Southern Pacific, which in turn was acquired by the Union Pacific in 1996. To recognize the city's prominent location as one of California's key railroad centers, the Southern Pacific constructed its Sacramento Depot in 1925. The architectural firm of Bliss & Faville designed the largely rectangular building in the Romanesque Revival style popularized by the famed H.H. RIchardson and similar to the Union Stations in both Hartford and St. Louis


Today, the depot is known as Sacramento Valley Station and hosts as much, if not more activity than in its heyday. Four different Amtrak routes serve the station: Amtrak California's Capitol Corridor and San Joaquins, providing intrastate service, and the long-distance California Zephyr – connecting Chicago and Emeryville, Calif – and the Coast Starlight, which links Seattle with Los Angeles. All told, that's 40 weekday trains serving Sacramento (a couple fewer Capitol Corridor trains operate on the weekends). Moreover, the Capitol Corridor operates one of its daily roundtrips east of Sacramento to Placer County to reach Roseville, Rocklin and Auburn, heading into Sacramento in the morning and out in the evening to function as commuter service. The amount of traffic makes Sacramento Amtrak's second-busiest station in California after Los Angeles and more than 1.1 million Amtrak passengers traveled through the station in 2009.

And yet while intercity rail options in Sacramento are burgeoning, passengers connecting to or from these trains find themselves with substantial options to access the metropolitan region or elsewhere in the state. As part of its statewide rail program (note: please see our full-length feature article, "California's Railroad" in RAIL #11), a broad network of intercity bus routes are also operated. In Sacramento, Amtrak California bus routes head north to Medford, Ore, west to Fairfield and Suisun, and east to both Reno/Sparks and Lake Tahoe, Nev. Bus connections are coordinated to match Amtrak departures, especially so for the Capitol Corridor and San Joaquins routes. 

Meanwhile, local transit connections at Valley Station abound. In December 2006, Sacramento's Regional Transit District (RT) extended its Gold Line light-rail to the station. Light-rail trains heading to Sunrise and others all the way to Johnny Cash's fabled Folsom stop on an adjacent platform to Amtrak trains. At the same time, RT's J Street bus routes (#s 30 and 31) call at the station. A taxi cue at the front entrance of the station offers additional options to travel through the city, and ample bicycle racks and space encourage non-motorized travel. Likewise, just a couple hundred feet away from the end of the platforms, a well-marked path guides visitors to the fine California State Railroad Museum and Old Sacramento State Historic Park. And given the station's position at the northwest corner of the city's downtown, nearly all of the central business district and state capitol office buildings are within walking distance (although the RT's light-rail and bus options would probably get you there faster). 

If Valley Station's claim as a model for intermodal locations wasn't already established, plentiful space exists on the north side of the existing station platforms to host a full-scale high-speed rail terminal. Land that used to support the Southern Pacific's extensive yards and shops (see photo to the left) now lies in wait for California's high-speed rail network to reaffirm the city's role as a rail hotbed. Corresponding with those efforts are plans to transform the former yards owned first by the Southern Pacific and later the Union Pacific into one of the nation's largest transit-oriented development projects. While work is just beginning, the project is expected to transform the Southern Pacific's Central Shops building into a public marketplace, offer expanded space for the Railroad Museum, include over 12,000 housing units and create 19,000 jobs. Projected to include at lease $5 billion in private investment, the project will include over 240 acres and last well into the next decade.

In all, Sacramento's Valley Station offers an outstanding example of achievement and opportunity in modern intermodal transportation facilities. It blends historical preservation with multiple and frequent service options in a location that is both convenient to existing activity and attractions, and nearby prime locations for new development. So, when detractors of well-designed intermodal facilities say "it can't be done," point them to Sacramento.



Monday, April 19, 2010

A Tale of Two Stations

Following last week's discussion of California's high-speed rail plans through the San Joaquin Valley, today we look at what remains of Fresno's passenger rail infrastructure. Currently, the lines of the Union Pacific and BNSF (representing the amalgamation of the former Burlington Northern and Santa Fe railroads) travel through the city. The rails of BNSF host Amtrak's San Joaquin trains, which we discussed yesterday. Those tracks were originally constructed by the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railroad (usually shortened to the Santa Fe) in the late 1800 to serve the burgeoning agricultural activity in the Valley. Accordingly, the railroad constructed a well-appointed station in the heart of Fresno at Tulare and P streets in its iconic mission-style architecture.


Featuring a moderately-sized passenger waiting area, ticket counters, baggage check facilities, wide platforms, and a freight office, the Santa Fe's Fresno station represents the quintessential smaller city train station. It is inviting, well laid-out, and speaks to the railroad's presence in the city. Fortunately, the Santa Fe depot is in full use today as a train station, hosting Amtrak's five daily roundtrip San Joaquins trains north to Oakland and Sacramento and south to Bakersfield. The photos below illustrate the facility's fine standard of upkeep to this day.






Meanwhile, westward down Tulare Street at the intersection of the Union Pacific tracks lies the former Southern Pacific depot. Union Pacific inherited the Southern Pacific (SP) – which itself grew out of the Central Pacific – route when the two roads merged in  1996. The SP built its first station at the same location in 1872, and the current facility replaced its predecessor in 1889. The station marked a sharp contrast with most of the railroad's other railroad buildings, which featured a more boxy, red brick-and-wood style. Instead, its Fresno depot was fashioned in the Queen Anne architectural tradition, included rounded turrets, interior tunnel hallways, and a hipped roof. Full details on the history and architectural features of the Southern Pacific depot can be found here


As passenger traffic on the line declined after the 1950's, the Southern Pacific was forced to abandon the station in 1971, when Amtrak assumed all passenger rail service in the nation and discontinued service to the San Joaquin valley. When service was restored in 1974, the San Joaquin trains instead served the Santa Fe station. Today, the station is listed on the National Register of Historic Places ensuring its continued preservation and is home to commercial and retail tenants. Trackside access to the Union Pacific right-of-way is prevented via a retaining wall. Also nearby is Chukchansi Park, home to the Fresno Grizzlies, a AAA affiliate of the San Francisco Giants, continuing the fine tradition of locating ballparks in close proximity to railroad infrastructure (see first photo below). 






The eventual route of California's high-speed rail system is expected to pass next to the Southern Pacific depot and include a new station at the location. The project is anticipated to anchor development at the west end of downtown Fresno by leveraging nearby Chuckansi Park along with the new rail station. See my previous post on high-speed rail in California for further details.  


Coming soon will be another look at one of California's historic rail depots: Sacramento's Valley Station, which serves as an outstanding example of true intermodalism, offering intercity rail and bus service, along with Sacramento Regional Transit's local light-rail and bus operations, taxi options, bicycle and pedestrian access. 
  

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Rail Through the Valley

While California's bleak fiscal outlook presents significant challenges to the implementation of state's planned high-speed rail network, and substantial debate and planning is underway to determine the alignment of the system through the Bay Area and into the Southern California basin, one of its strongest elements will be its passage through the San Joaquin Valley, which will represent the longest swaths of trackage on the network.

Already served by five daily roundtrip trains on Amtrak's conventional San Joaquins service between Oakland or Sacramento and Bakersfield, the Valley that is one of the world's most verdant and productive agricultural regions also exhibits the perfect conditions for a high-speed rail line: flat, straight terrain unencumbered by narrow rights-of-way or shoehorned-together urban densities. In fact, these very conditions pose the biggest obstacles to the line's corridors approaching San Francisco and Los Angeles.


Both Union Pacific and BNSF operate heavily-utilized freight corridors through the Valley – the former which hosts Amtrak's San Joaquins (see above photo of the UP corridor paralleling Highway 99). California's high-speed rail route will not operate over those tracks, however, but most likely parallel one of the routes, depending on factors such as right-of-way availability, population density, and infrastructure, such as bridges and tunnels. Regardless of the exact alignment chosen, the path through the San Joaquin Valley will allow California's high-speed trains to reach their highest speeds on the route, reaching up to 220 mph in some sections through the Valley. Some trains will make all stops along the line, including Valley communities like Fresno and Bakersfield, while other will operate as expresses between the Bay Area and Southern California, allowing for even shorter trip times. Fortunately, in Fresno, ample space is available downtown to locate a full-service intermodal station. Consider the images below contrasting the current area around the Union Pacific's tracks through Fresno with the renderings of the high-speed station planned for the city. (NOTE: Tune into the Potomac Express tomorrow for a comparison of the existing historic train stations in Fresno)































Tuesday, April 13, 2010

RAIL in the Air: PHX


If you happened to catch the most recent edition of RAIL, you noticed our focus on connections between air and rail travel. One of our brief profiles covered the work to construct an airport rail service at Phoenix's Sky Harbor International Airport (PHX). As you can see from the above photo, construction is well underway at PHX, as beams of concrete and steel rise above the tarmac. The first phase of PHX Sky Train is expected to open in 2013. It will also connect to Phoenix's Valley METRO Light Rail service.

And for all you rail enthusiasts who are also aviation observers, this photo was taken from a US Air A321 taxiing prior to departure to LAX.

Sunday, April 11, 2010

All Signals Green for Departure

This post marks the debut of RAIL Magazine's Potomac Express blog. This venue will bridge the gaps between our quarterly editions of RAIL and our monthly electronic newsletter, Fast Mail for RAIL. Since this is a blog, the Potomac Express will be presented in a less formal style and include postings as news and developments occur in the passenger rail industry, or simply when I have an idea to share or concept to discuss. This means sometimes there may be several posts in a week, and in other weeks none. Some will be more substantive, and others more brief.

In all, the Potomac Express represents another means to get you the latest happenings, trends and ideas in passenger rail, while also offering a new interactive medium for you to share your reactions and connect with other passenger rail leaders, experts, advocates and observers. As always, feel free to contact me at sampson@ctaa.org if you'd like to spread the word on any interesting news, resources or events.

In a bit of a preview of what's coming down the line in the Potomac Express in the days ahead, I'll be making a week-long visit to California to meet with leaders of community and public transit systems across the state, and you can expect some intermittent posts as I encounter some of the the Golden State's numerous passenger rail services, stations and vehicles along the way. This could include some original photography, passing thoughts on nuances of the various operations and perhaps some details or commentary on the state's evolving effort on high-speed rail.